We develop a distributed second order optimization algorithm that is communication-efficient as well as robust against Byzantine failures of the worker machines. We propose an iterative approximate Newton-type algorithm, where the worker machines communicate \emph{only once} per iteration with the central machine. This is in sharp contrast with the state-of-the-art distributed second order algorithms like GIANT \cite{giant}, DINGO\cite{dingo}, where the worker machines send (functions of) local gradient and Hessian sequentially; thus ending up communicating twice with the central machine per iteration. Furthermore, we employ a simple norm based thresholding rule to filter-out the Byzantine worker machines. We establish the linear-quadratic rate of convergence of our proposed algorithm and establish that the communication savings and Byzantine resilience attributes only correspond to a small statistical error rate for arbitrary convex loss functions. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work that addresses the issue of Byzantine resilience in second order distributed optimization. Furthermore, we validate our theoretical results with extensive experiments on synthetically generated and benchmark LIBSVM \cite{libsvm} data-set and demonstrate convergence guarantees.

This work is a solid contribution to the literature on distributed optimization/training. Three reviewers suggested acceptance, and one suggested weak reject. I believe the concerns raised by this reviewer are not major and can (and should) be addressed in the camera ready version. I suggest acceptance provided the authors are ready to address all reasonable issues raised by the reviewers. Some more comments: Plus: There is a consensus that the paper's contributions are quite clear despite the dense content. I recommend some more details be added in the extra page available in the camera ready version.

We develop a distributed second order optimization algorithm that is communication-efficient as well as robust against Byzantine failures of the worker machines. We propose an iterative approximate Newton-type algorithm, where the worker machines communicate \emph{only once} per iteration with the central machine. This is in sharp contrast with the state-of-the-art distributed second order algorithms like GIANT \cite{giant}, DINGO\cite{dingo}, where the worker machines send (functions of) local gradient and Hessian sequentially; thus ending up communicating twice with the central machine per iteration. Furthermore, we employ a simple norm based thresholding rule to filter-out the Byzantine worker machines. We establish the linear-quadratic rate of convergence of our proposed algorithm and establish that the communication savings and Byzantine resilience attributes only correspond to a small statistical error rate for arbitrary convex loss functions.